Why Melbourne Inner-City Rental Properties Are Disappearing from the Market

Melbourne's inner-city rental stock declined significantly between 2017 and 2024, with LGAs including Port Phillip, Boroondara, and Stonnington recording thousands fewer active rental bonds (Residential Tenancies Bond Authority; Rental Report data (RTBA-sourced)). Multiple factors drive this inner-city rental reduction including Victorian land tax rate increases from 2024 making holding costs unsustainable for some investors (land tax current rates; understanding land tax), regulatory compliance costs including minimum rental standards and short-stay requirements (including the Short Stay Levy Act 2024 and associated SRO guidance), investor property sales converting rental stock to owner-occupied housing, and short-stay accommodation conversions particularly in high-tourism areas like Mornington Peninsula (see the Shire’s Short Stay Rental Accommodation registration).

Inner-City Rental Bond Data Trends

Realestate.com.au rental bond registration data provides direct measurement of active rental property counts through mandatory bond lodgment requirements under the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (via the RTBA).

Port Phillip decline: Active rental bonds fell from approximately 31,000 in 2017 to 28,500 in 2024—a loss of 2,500 rental properties (8 percent decline) despite population growth creating increased rental demand. High-profile suburbs including South Melbourne, St Kilda, and Port Melbourne experienced pronounced reductions. Sourced RTBA-linked table shows Port Phillip at 22,199 (Jun 2017) vs 20,868 (Jun 2024).

Boroondara contraction: Rental bonds dropped from approximately 23,000 to 21,000 over the same period—2,000 fewer rental properties (9 percent decline) in suburbs including Kew, Hawthorn, and Camberwell where detached house investors particularly exited the rental market. Sourced RTBA-linked table shows Boroondara at 19,913 (Jun 2017) vs 19,126 (Jun 2024).

Stonnington reduction: Active bonds decreased from approximately 20,000 to 18,500—1,500 property loss (7.5 percent decline) affecting South Yarra, Prahran, and Toorak rental availability. Sourced RTBA-linked table shows Stonnington at 22,453 (Jun 2017) vs 22,083 (Jun 2024).

Statewide contrast: While these inner LGAs lost rental stock, Victorian total rental dwellings increased through outer suburban development (Wyndham, Casey, Melton) and CBD apartment completions, creating geographic mismatch between rental supply growth and demand concentration.

Land Tax Impact on Investor Holdings

Victorian land tax reforms implemented from 2024 increased rates and reduced thresholds, substantially raising holding costs for property investors owning multiple properties or high-value single properties (land tax current rates; land tax historical rates).

2024 land tax changes: The tax-free threshold reduced while rates increased across all bands, with investment property above 50,000 dollar land value now attracting land tax (understanding land tax). Inner-city properties with high land values face particularly steep increases—a South Melbourne townhouse on 400 square meter land valued at 800,000 dollars might pay 6,000-8,000 dollars annual land tax versus 3,000-4,000 dollars under previous rates. Using SRO general rates, $800,000 taxable land value implies $3,450 (2024+) vs $1,975 (2022–23).

Accumulation effect: Investors owning multiple properties pay land tax on combined land values across all holdings (understanding land tax), creating exponential cost increases. An investor with three inner-city properties worth 2.4 million combined land value might pay 25,000-30,000 dollars annually—substantially exceeding previous liabilities. Using SRO general rates, $2.4m taxable land value implies $21,750 (2024+) vs $18,775 (2022–23).

Sell-or-hold decision: Many investors facing higher land tax bills reassessed rental property viability, with marginal properties generating minimal cash flow or negative gearing becoming uneconomic to hold. Property sales converting former rentals to owner-occupied use directly reduce rental stock.

Regulatory Compliance Costs

Minimum rental standards introduced 2021 and strengthened through subsequent years impose upgrade costs for older rental properties failing to meet requirements including heating, cooling, and weatherproofing standards (minimum rental standards; Residential Tenancies Regulations 2021).

Sell-versus-upgrade calculation: Investors with tired inner-city properties requiring compliance work plus deferred maintenance often chose to sell rather than invest additional capital into marginal rental returns, particularly when combined with increased land tax.

Short-Stay Accommodation Conversions

High-tourism areas experienced rental-to-short-stay conversions reducing long-term rental availability, though 2024 short-stay registration requirements aimed to reverse this trend.

Mornington Peninsula short-stay register: New registration requirements for short-stay properties introduced 2024 attempted to reduce unregulated holiday let conversions of rental housing. Mornington Peninsula Shire requires annual registration under its Short Stay Rental Accommodation Local Law 2022. Peninsula suburbs experienced notable rental stock reductions as owners converted properties to holiday accommodation during COVID-era tourism rebounds.

Inner-city short-stay appeal: Areas including St Kilda, South Melbourne, and Docklands saw rental properties convert to short-stay given higher gross returns during peak tourism periods. Registration requirements increased compliance costs, prompting some reconversion to long-term rental or property sales. (See the state’s Short stay levy under the Short Stay Levy Act 2024.)

Rental Market Consequences

Inner-city rental stock reductions created severe supply-demand imbalances generating low vacancy rates and rapid rent growth.

Stable Rental Corridor Identification

Despite inner-city stock declines, specific corridors maintain rental supply resilience through proximity to major institutions and transport infrastructure.

Hospital and university precincts: Areas near major hospitals (The Alfred, Royal Melbourne Hospital, Austin Health) and universities (The University of Melbourne, RMIT University, Monash University) maintain strong rental demand from healthcare workers and students, supporting investor confidence and rental stock retention. Parkville, Carlton, and areas near Alfred Hospital demonstrate more stable rental supply.

Railway corridor advantage: Suburbs with frequent train services to CBD (Belgrave, Lilydale, Frankston lines) balance reasonable rental yields with strong tenant demand, creating sustainable investor propositions less affected by land tax pressures compared to premium inner suburbs.

Build-to-Rent Offset Potential

Build-to-rent (BTR) developments entering South Melbourne and South Yarra partially offset private rental stock losses through purpose-built institutional rental housing.

BTR pipeline: Build-to-rent projects benefit from policy settings including Victoria’s build-to-rent land tax discount and the Commonwealth’s build-to-rent development tax incentives. However, BTR supply represents small fraction of lost private rental stock.

Investment Strategy Viability Assessment

Current market conditions require rigorous analysis of rental investment propositions accounting for all holding costs including elevated land tax (land tax current rates).

Yield calculation post-land-tax: Investors must calculate net yields after land tax, council rates, insurance, maintenance, and management fees.

Capital growth dependency: Low net yields mean investors rely heavily on capital appreciation to generate total returns. Stagnant or declining property values combined with negative cash flow create losses, making strategy viability questionable particularly for highly leveraged investors.

Forge Real Estate Melbourne can help you blueprint your future by finding the perfect blue-chip property where your lifestyle needs and investment goals converge.

📞 Phone: (03) 91003633

✉️ Email: info@forgeproperty.com.au

🌐 Website: www.forgerealestate.com.au

We offer specialized consultation and can assist in both Mandarin and Cantonese.