Why Properties Pass In at Auction and How to Identify Value After Failed Sales

Properties pass in at auction—failing to sell when bidding does not reach vendor reserve prices—due to unrealistic vendor price expectations misaligned with market evidence, property-specific limitations including poor accessibility or outdated design reducing buyer appeal, misleading price guide ranges understating actual reserve prices and discouraging appropriate buyer segments, and broader market cooling reducing buyer competition and willingness to pay premium prices. (Victoria definitions: if bids don’t meet reserve the property may be “passed in,” and the highest bidder gets first right to negotiate: Consumer Affairs Victoria – Buying property at auction. Underquoting/price guidance context: Consumer Affairs Victoria – Understanding property prices and underquoting.)

Melbourne inner-city suburbs including Fitzroy, Collingwood, and Brunswick demonstrate pass-in rates of 25 to 40 percent during market downturns, with passed-in properties typically remaining on market 40 to 90 days longer than properties selling at initial auctions.
Post-auction private negotiations enable buyers to purchase at 5 to 15 percent below initial reserve prices as vendors confront market reality and adjust expectations, though not all passed-in properties represent value opportunities—some fail due to genuine defects or constraints justifying lower prices.

Common Reasons Properties Pass In

Vendor price expectations exceed market reality: Vendors often anchor expectations to recent peak prices, renovations they've completed, or emotional attachment to properties rather than objective market evidence. When reserves significantly exceed what comparable properties recently achieved, insufficient buyers bid at those levels, causing pass-ins. (On reserve/passed-in mechanics in Victoria: Consumer Affairs Victoria.)

Misleading price guide ranges: Some agents use understated price guides to attract buyer interest—advertising properties at 800,000-850,000 dollars while vendors hold 950,000 dollar reserves. This mismatch draws buyers who cannot afford actual asking prices, resulting in auction crowds without qualified bidders at reserve levels. (Price advertising/underquoting rules and buyer guidance: Consumer Affairs Victoria.)

Property-specific limitations: Structural or design issues reduce buyer pools. Inner-Melbourne townhouses with poor stair access between levels deter buyers with mobility concerns or families with young children. Narrow single-car garages in neighborhoods where two-car parking is standard limit appeal. Properties backing onto busy roads face noise concerns. These constraints don't prevent sales but require price adjustments reflecting reduced desirability.

Market timing and sentiment: Auctions scheduled during interest rate increase periods, economic uncertainty, or seasonal low-activity times face reduced buyer competition. Fewer bidders mean lower probability of reaching reserves, even for well-priced properties.

Inner-City Example: Fitzroy and Collingwood Townhouses

Fitzroy and Collingwood Victorian-era terrace conversions and modern townhouses demonstrate specific pass-in patterns related to design and access constraints.

Stair access issues: Multi-level townhouses with three or four floors and narrow staircases appeal to young, fit buyers but deter families with children, older buyers, or anyone concerned about long-term livability as mobility changes. Properties with all bedrooms on upper floors—no ground-level bedroom option—face particular resistance.

Limited natural light: Terrace properties with narrow frontages and neighboring buildings close on both sides often suffer from limited natural light in middle rooms. Buyers increasingly prioritize light-filled spaces, making darker configurations harder to sell at premium prices.

Parking constraints: Single narrow garages or no off-street parking in suburbs where most comparable properties offer adequate parking create competitive disadvantages requiring price adjustments.

Design quirks: Open-plan layouts with bedrooms visible from living areas, bathrooms without proper ventilation, or kitchens in awkward locations reduce appeal. While these don't make properties unsellable, they require pricing acknowledging layout compromises.

Days on Market and Discount Trends

Properties passing in at auction face extended marketing periods and price reductions before eventual sale.

Extended marketing timelines: Passed-in properties average 60-90 days total marketing time versus 30-45 days for properties selling at initial auctions in Melbourne inner-city markets. Extended campaigns erode vendor negotiating positions as ongoing holding costs and psychological fatigue increase willingness to accept lower offers.

Typical discount patterns: Properties eventually selling after pass-ins achieve 5-15 percent below initial reserves on average, though ranges vary widely. Properties passing in due to minor reserve-market misalignment may sell at 3-5 percent reductions. Properties with significant defects or constraints may require 15-25 percent reductions to find buyers.

Relisting versus private negotiation: Some vendors immediately pursue private negotiations with underbidders or new buyers post-auction. Others withdraw properties, adjust expectations, and relist weeks later at revised price guides. Private treaty post-auction negotiations often occur within 7-14 days while buyer interest remains warm. (Victoria: after a property is “passed in,” the highest bidder gets first right to negotiate, and agents may approach other bidders if no agreement is reached: Consumer Affairs Victoria.)

Separating Red Flags from Hidden Value

Not all passed-in properties represent bargains—some fail for legitimate reasons justifying lower prices or continued market resistance.

Red flag indicators: Properties passing in multiple times at progressively lower reserves suggest significant issues beyond pricing. Extensive days on market (120-plus days) indicates serious buyer reluctance. Properties with visible structural issues, significant building defects, or planning permit problems warrant caution regardless of price reductions.

Hidden value opportunities: Well-maintained properties in desirable locations passing in due to vendor stubbornness rather than property issues present opportunities. Properties with cosmetic drawbacks (dated kitchens, old carpets) that buyers can remedy inexpensively may offer value when vendors over-adjust prices downward assuming cosmetic issues severely impact value.

Research comparable sales: Investigate what similar properties actually sold for (not just listed for) in the previous three months. If a passed-in Collingwood townhouse has a revised 950,000 dollar private sale price but comparable townhouses sold for 920,000-940,000 dollars, it's approaching market reality. If comparables sold for 850,000-880,000 dollars, it remains overpriced despite reductions. (Auction results sources: Domain Melbourne auction results and realestate.com.au’s guide to auction results status definitions.)

Post-Auction Negotiation Strategy

Buyers can leverage passed-in situations for favorable negotiations when approaching vendors strategically.

Timing matters: Contact agents within 48-72 hours post-auction while vendors feel disappointment but before they've mentally reset expectations. Immediate post-auction periods create maximum vendor motivation.

Reference market evidence: Present comparable sales data supporting offer prices. Vendors respond more favorably to evidence-based offers than lowball offers lacking justification. Demonstrating genuine market research shows serious intent.

Acknowledge property positives: Frame negotiations positively—"We love the location and layout, but our budget reflects current market conditions for properties with [specific constraint]"—rather than criticizing properties, which triggers defensive vendor responses.

Pre-approval strength: Demonstrate financial readiness through unconditional pre-approval and deposit availability. Vendors prioritize certain sales over higher uncertain offers, particularly after auction disappointments.

Request agent insights: Ask agents directly why properties passed in and what vendors now expect. Agents often reveal realistic selling ranges post-auction that weren't disclosed pre-auction, providing negotiation guidance.

Victorian Private Sale Process After Pass-In

Post-auction private sales in Victoria follow standard private treaty processes including mandatory Section 32 vendor statements, cooling-off periods (three business days with 0.2 percent penalty), and negotiable settlement terms (see Consumer Affairs Victoria on Section 32 vendor statements and contracts and the cooling-off rules in Buying property by private sale).

Price guide adjustments: Properties relisted after pass-ins typically show revised price guides closer to market reality. Compare original guides to revised guides—large reductions signal vendor expectation adjustments creating negotiation opportunities.

Subject-to-finance protection: Unlike auction purchases, private treaty sales allow subject-to-finance clauses protecting buyers from valuation shortfalls or loan rejection. This reduced risk enables more confident offers near upper budget limits. (Victoria guidance: conditional offers including “subject to finance” in private sales, and that buyers can’t place conditions at auction: Consumer Affairs Victoria and Buying property at auction.)

Evidence-Based Assessment

Passed-in properties require careful analysis distinguishing legitimate value opportunities from problem properties justifying continued market resistance. Thorough due diligence including building inspections, comparable sales research, and professional valuations prevents buyers from assuming all discounted properties represent bargains.

Vendors facing pass-ins benefit from objective market feedback validating realistic pricing. Agents providing evidence-based appraisals help vendors set achievable expectations, increasing sale probability during private negotiations.

Service note: Forge Real Estate offers free appraisals providing objective market value assessments for both vendors setting realistic reserves and buyers evaluating passed-in opportunities. Services include property sales, purchases, and management across Melbourne's inner-city suburbs.

Forge Real Estate Melbourne can help you blueprint your future by finding the perfect blue-chip property where your lifestyle needs and investment goals converge.

📞 Phone: (03) 91003633

✉️ Email: info@forgeproperty.com.au

🌐 Website: www.forgerealestate.com.au

We offer specialized consultation and can assist in both Mandarin and Cantonese.