How to Navigate Melbourne Auctions in 2026 Despite Underquoting and Rate Uncertainty

Melbourne auction markets in 2026 face persistent underquoting alongside RBA cash rate stability at 3.60 percent (unchanged since June 2025 the cash rate has been at 3.60% since the last cut in August 2025), creating sustained borrowing capacity constraints while auction competition remains meaningful (track weekly results via sources like Domain’s Melbourne auction results). Buyers should rely on the agent’s Statement of Information and recent comparable sales to establish realistic expectations rather than trusting advertised guides. Pre-auction preparation including comparable analysis, firm walk-away price determination based on genuine market evidence, and emotional discipline during bidding prevent overpayment driven by auction psychology where winning becomes priority over value assessment.

Underquoting Patterns and Price Guide Interpretation

Common underquoting tactics: Agents may set an indicative selling price that doesn’t match buyer expectations or current competition, pulling in extra interest from buyers who later find the property is out of reach. In Victoria, if a property advertisement includes a price, it must be a single figure or a range of up to 10 per cent and cannot use qualifying words like “from”, “offers above”, or “+” (rules explained by Consumer Affairs Victoria).

Reserve price disclosure: Victorian reforms require reserve disclosure seven days before auctions, providing concrete price floors. Announced in November 2025 and proposed to be introduced in 2026, the reform would require publishing the reserve price at least seven days before auction or fixed-date sale.

Reading between the lines: Always cross-check the guide against the comparable sales in the Statement of Information and your own recent sales research, and treat the guide as a starting point, not a promise.

RBA Rate Stability and Borrowing Capacity

The 3.60 percent cash rate (December 2025 hold) creates sustained borrowing capacity constraints. (RBA confirms the cash rate setting; for context on 2026 expectations and how rates flow through to borrowers, see this ABC explainer.)

Implications for buyers: Waiting for rate cuts carries risk that price growth outpaces serviceability improvements.

Auction Clearance Rates and Market Temperature

Melbourne’s clearance rates move week to week and can be noisy around holiday periods and low volume, so use consistent tracking rather than a single weekend. (One public tracker is Domain’s Melbourne auction results.)

Comparable Sales Research Strategy

12-week window: Research properties sold within past 8-12 weeks matching target property location, size, condition, and features. Older sales (4-6 months) may not reflect current market momentum in rapidly changing conditions.

Adjustment factors: Comparable properties rarely match perfectly. Adjust for differences—properties with renovated kitchens command 20,000-40,000 dollar premiums over similar unrenovated stock; north-facing apartments sell 30,000-50,000 dollars above south-facing equivalents in same buildings.

Walk-Away Price Determination

Pre-auction commitment: Set maximum bid limits before auctions based on borrowing capacity, comparable evidence, and personal value assessment—not auction competition dynamics. Write this number down and commit to stopping when reached.

Calculation methodology: Identify realistic market value from comparable analysis, subtract 5 percent creating competitive but disciplined limit (if comparables indicate 950,000 dollar value, set walk-away at 900,000-905,000 dollars enabling competitive bidding without overpaying).

Emotional discipline: Auction environments trigger escalation commitment where bidders exceed rational limits to "win." Pre-determined limits combined with accountability partners (family, buyers' agents) enforce discipline preventing regret purchases.

Private Sale Versus Auction Considerations

Properties passing in at auction or withdrawn before auction enter private treaty negotiations where buyers gain advantages including subject-to-finance clauses protecting against valuation shortfalls or loan rejection, cooling-off periods (three days with 0.2 percent penalty) allowing purchase reconsideration, and reduced competitive pressure enabling considered decisions rather than auction urgency. (Cooling-off rules and the 0.2%/$100 penalty are set out by Consumer Affairs Victoria; note cooling-off generally does not apply if you buy at auction](https://www.consumer.vic.gov.au/housing/buying-and-selling-property/buying-property/buying-property-at-auction).)

Buyers should monitor passed-in properties contacting agents within 48-72 hours post-auction while vendor disappointment creates negotiation opportunities. Evidence-based offers referencing comparable sales strengthen positions more than arbitrary lowball offers.

Sydney Versus Melbourne Comparative Value

Sydney median prices substantially exceed Melbourne—Sydney houses averaging 1,450,000-1,550,000 dollars versus Melbourne 1,020,000-1,050,000 dollars (January 2026)—creating relative Melbourne value proposition for buyers comparing east coast markets. For a current, consistent benchmark, Cotality’s Home Value Index shows median dwelling values of $1,280,613 (Sydney) and $827,117 (Melbourne) as at December 2025.

However, Sydney's higher prices reflect employment concentration, infrastructure investment, and constrained supply that may produce stronger long-term capital growth offsetting higher entry costs. Melbourne offers better affordability enabling property market entry for median-income buyers excluded from Sydney markets.

First Home Buyer Auction Strategy

Pre-approval priority: Obtain unconditional pre-approval including property valuation before auction attendance. Conditional pre-approval risks valuation shortfalls or loan rejection after winning bids. (ASIC’s Moneysmart explains what pre-approval does and doesn’t mean.)

Attend practice auctions: Visit 3-5 auctions for properties you're not purchasing, observing bidding dynamics, auctioneer techniques, and competitor behavior without financial pressure.

Consider buyer representation: First-time buyers benefit substantially from professional representation navigating auction psychology, bidding tactics, and price assessment without emotional attachment affecting judgment.

Forge Real Estate Melbourne can help you blueprint your future by finding the perfect blue-chip property where your lifestyle needs and investment goals converge.

📞 Phone: (03) 91003633

✉️ Email: info@forgeproperty.com.au

🌐 Website: www.forgerealestate.com.au

We offer specialized consultation and can assist in both Mandarin and Cantonese.